Explanation of Texas case vs Deferred Action


On Thursday January 15, 2015, U.S. District Judge Andrew Hanen heard oral argument on a challenge to two of President Obama’s initiatives that he announced on November 20, 2014.

  1. The expansion of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA); and
  2. The creation of the Deferred Action for Parental Accountability (DAPA) program.

Both programs give their recipients protection from deportation for three years, employment authorization, and the ability to apply for a social security number and a state issued driver’s license.

Texas initiated a lawsuit to stop the DACA and DAPA programs and 24 other states, mostly Republicans, joined the lawsuit against the program.  The States have two main arguments against the programs:

  1. The President has violated Article II, Section 3 of the U.S. Constitution knowns as the Take Care Clause.  This provision means that the President must take care that the Laws be faithfully executed; and
  2. They argue that he had violated the Administrative Procedure Act.

What the States are really saying is that the President has exceeded the scope of his authority by creating the DACA and DAPA programs.

I disagree.  What the President has done is consistent with precedent and what prior administrations have done.  The only question is the sheer number of people it can help, but there is no legal basis to find something unconstitutional based on numbers alone.  When you consider percentages, what the President has done is consistent with prior administrations, there were just fewer people affected.  I am confident that Executive Action will be upheld as a proper exercise of the President’s authority, but the case has to go through the process.

January 15, 2015, hearing focused on the State’s request for a preliminary injunction.  The States are arguing that if the Court doesn’t immediately stop the implementation of the DACA and DAPA programs by the time they ultimately win it won’t matter.  To get an injunction (Stop the government from implementing the program) the States must show:

  1. They will be probably succeeded on the merits of the case;
  2. That they will be irreparably harmed (generally money won’t solve the problem) if the Federal Government isn’t stopped from implementing the DACA and DAPA program;
  3. That the State’s will be harmed greater than the Federal Government if the injunction isn’t granted; and
  4. That the public interest favors the States.

The States have a problem with the first two elements.  The first means that they have a good chance of winning the overall case.  That is highly unlikely in my opinion.  The second is that the States will be irreparably harmed if the injunction is granted.  Here also they have a problem.  They have a hard time showing that giving undocumented immigrants work authorization and protection from deportation will harm the States.  Prior law already requires states to educate all kids regardless of immigration status.  Undocumented immigrants don’t get public benefits under this program.  So then where is the harm to the states caused by this program?  They really can’t articulate it.  For those two reasons alone they are likely to fail to get the injunction.

Judge Hanen didn’t make a decision on January 15, 2015.  The judge gave the government until January 30, 2015, to submit an additional brief.  We expect the Judge’s decision shortly thereafter, probably the first week of February.  It remains to be seen what Judge Hanen will do.  Irrespective of his decision–in favor of the Government or in favor of the States–his decision will be appealed to the Fifth Circuit.

If you have any questions about this case or DACA or DAPA programs generally you can,

  1. Call 888-695-6169 to speak to our knowledgeable staff;
  2. Fill out the contact us form on this page;
  3. Select the live chat feature to speak to someone right away.

We help immigrants, one court case at a time.

Share This Post!

Related Posts

Call Us Today!


New Jersey Immigration Attorney

Need help?

Got questions?

New Jersey Immigration Attorney

We're here 24/7.
Call Now!



Eatontown, NJ


Address

286 RT 35
Unit D
Eatontown, NJ 07724

Map/Directions

Lakewood, NJ


Address

212 2nd Street
Suite 104
Lakewood, NJ 08701

Map/Directions

Newark, NJ


Address

50 Park Place
Suite #1101
Newark, NJ 07102

Map/Directions

Edison, NJ


Address

1929 NJ-27
Edison, NJ 08817

Map/Directions
Address

1065 US-22 Suite 2B
Bridgewater Township, NJ 08807

Map/Directions

Freehold, NJ


Address

36 W Main St, Suite 302,
Freehold, NJ 07728

Map/Directions

Copyright 2021 Provencher and Flatt, LLP - All Rights Reserved. Powered by Advantage Attorney Marketing & Cloud Solutions

Immigration Attorney

Ask an Immigration Attorney

Ask a question or tell us about your situation, we are happy to help!

Arrested in New Jersey

Request Your Free Copy

Solicite su copia gratuita

Immigration Book

Request Your Free Copy

Solicite su copia gratuita

Immigration Attorney

Request Your Free Copy

Solicite su copia gratuita

Find Out Immediately If You Qualify for Legal Status

Subheading

Your privacy is important to us. We will keep the information you provide strictly confidential. We only use your information to determine if you may be eligible for immigration benefits in the United States. The information we provide should not be construed as legal advice and submission of this form does not create an attorney/client relationship.

Ingrese la siguiente información para aceptar los términos y condiciones.

Enter the following information to accept the terms and conditions.

Start Here!

Información Personal / Personal Information

Subheading

Idioma Preferido*

Preferred Language

Fecha Nacimiento*

Date of Birth

Pais de Nacimiento*

Country of Birth

Entradas a las EEUU / Entries into the US

Subheading

Fecha Entrada*

Date of Entry

Entrada Legal*

Did you enter legally?

Background

Subheading

¿Tiene usted padres, conyuge o hijos mayores de 21 anos,Que ha estado o esta en las fuerzas armadas Americanas?*

Do you have a parent, spouse, or child over 21 who is or was in the US military?

¿Tiene usted padres,conyuge o hijos mayores de 21 anos, ciudadanos Americanos o residentes permanentes?*

Do you have a parent, spouse, or child over 21 who is a US citizen or lawful permanent resident?

¿Ha tenido usted, sus padres o sus abuelos un estado legal en los EEUU?*

Did you, your parents, or your grandparents ever have legal status in the U.S.?

¿Esta considerando matrimonio con us ciudadano Americano o residente permanente? ( mismo sexo incluido)*

Are you considering marriage to a US citizen or green card holder (same-sex marriage included)?

Background

Subheading

¿Alguien ha peticionado a su favor por motivos de inmigración?*

Has anyone ever filed an immigration petition for you before?

¿Ha sido usted deportado o esta usted en procedimiento de deportación ahora?*

Have you ever been deported or are you in deportation proceedings now?

Ha sido abusado por sus padres, conyuge o hijo mayor de edad?*

Has your parent, spouse, or adult child been abusive to you?

¿Si es asi, fue previo a Abril 30 del 2001?*

If so, was it before April 30, 2001?

Background

Subheading

¿Fue usted, conyuge, sus padres, pareja o sus hijos victimas de de un crimen violento en los EEUU?*

Were you, your parents, siblings, spouse, partner, or children a victim of a violent crime in the US?

¿Es usted menor de 21 años y soltero?*

Are you under 21 and not married?

¿Tiene usted un padre, conyuge o hijo menor de 15 anos con requerimientos especiales médicos (dificultades de estudio, alergias severas, asma u otra condición medica severa)?*

Do you have a parent, spouse, or child under 15 with medical or special needs (learning disability, severe allergies or asthma, or other serious medical condition)?

¿Fue usted maltratado, abusado o abandonado por sus padres?*

Did your parents mistreat, abuse, or abandon you?

Background

Subheading

¿Tenia usted 30 anos o menos en Junio, 15, 2012?*

Were you 30 years or under on June 15, 2012?

¿Tenía usted 15 años o menos en su primera entrada en los EEUU?*

Were you 15 years old or younger on your first entry into the US?

Click below now to see if you qualify!

¡Haga clic abajo ahora para ver si califica!

Free Deportation Risk Assessment

Where you ever caught at by immigration and returned to your country? (¿Dónde alguna vez te pilló inmigrando y regresaste a tu país?)*

Have you ever been arrested for any reason? (¿Alguna vez te han arrestado por alguna razón?)*

How many times have been arrested? (¿Cuántas veces han sido arrestados?)*

Were you arrested for any of the following reasons? (Check all that apply) (¿Te arrestaron por alguna de las siguientes razones?)

Have you ever filed for an immigration benefit and been denied? (¿Alguna vez ha presentado un beneficio de inmigración y se le ha negado?)*

Have you entered the US illegally more than once after 1997? (¿Ha entrado ilegalmente en los Estados Unidos más de una vez después de 1997?)*

Do you owe back child support? (¿Debes manutención infantil?)*

New Jersey Immigration Attorney

Get Instant Access

Enter your name and email address below to get instant access.

New Jersey Immigration Attorney


¡Obtenga acceso instantáneo ahora!

Ingrese su nombre y dirección de correo electrónico a continuación