Find out if you are truly at risk!
Find out instantly with our free deportation risk assessment
Despite this definition, it is still unclear which offenses Department of Homeland Security (DHS) will deem significant. Without additional clarification, many potential applicants, like Ernesto, will not know whether they are eligible for deferred action. Generally, a DUI conviction doesn’t carry immigration consequences. However, for this program, DHS says that a single DUI is a significant misdemeanor. DHS should recognize that not all DUIs are the same, and thus, not all DUI convictions should bar deferred action. All 50 states criminalize driving with a blood alcohol content (BAC) of .08 or above. However, New Jersey also punishes a person under 21 for driving with a BAC of .01. This zero tolerance law is not about public safety, but to prevent persons from drinking and driving as adults. If no distinction is made between adult and youth DUIs for purposes of the deferred action, young drivers the very population this policy is meant to helpwill be negatively and disparately impacted. DHS should consider mitigating factors and positive equities before determining that someone like Ernesto, an otherwise eligible applicant, is barred due to a single DUI. Ernesto learned his lesson. It was not evidence of an ongoing problem. Without more, there is no indication that he is a threat to public safety. For example, what if Ernesto was (1) charged with a DUI for sitting intoxicated in an inoperable vehicle, or (2) biking while intoxicated, in neither case is he a danger to others.